Carrie Ann & Co. is North Florida and South Georgia’s premiere catering specialists. Let Carrie Ann & Co., Inc. cater your next event at the Mays House or the venue of your choice. See our standard catering menus below. All of our menus may be modified in any way or we can customize a specialty catering menu for you “from scratch”. Visit our photo galleries for other ideas.

We’re always more than happy to personalize your catering menu for any event.

    • Breakfast/Brunch

    • Crème Brulee French Toast

      $9.95 per person

      Crème Brulee French Toast, Fruit Kabobs Grilled, Smoked Sausage, Apple Caramel Cake, Cappuccino Bars, Assorted Juices and Coffee

    • Egg, Sausage, & Cheese Casserole

      $10.95 per person

      Egg, Sausage, & Cheese Casserole, Fruit Salad Sliced, Smoked Ham, Assorted Mini Muffins, Biscuits, Assorted Juices and Coffee

    • Fruit Tray Plus

      $8.95 per person

      Fruit Tray, Assorted Mini Muffins, Sour Cream Coffee Cake, Mini Quiche, Sausage Cheeseballs, Assorted Juices and Coffee

    • Shrimp and Grits

      $13.95 per person

      Shrimp and Grits, Angel Biscuits, Cinnamon Crumble Cake, Mini Cinnamon Rolls, Fruit Tray, Assorted Juices and Coffee

    • Spinach & Onion Quiche

      $10.95 per person

      Spinach & Onion Quiche, Smoked Sausage, Orange Pecan Pulley Bread, Lemon Curd & Lime Curd Tartlets, Assorted Juices and Coffee

    • Reception

    • Cheese & Crackers

      Cheese & Crackers

      $7.95 per person

      Cheesemold w/Assorted Crackers, Stuffed Cucumber Cups, Assorted Vegetables w/Dip, Hot Crab Dip w/Crackers, Assorted Bar Cookies

    • Finger Sandwiches

      $7.95 per person

      Finger Sandwiches, Tartlet Shells with Chicken Salad, Fruit and Cheese Tray w/Assorted Crackers, Stuffed Cherry Tomatoes, Nuts

    • Finger Sandwiches Deluxe

      Finger Sandwiches Deluxe

      $12.95 per person

      Finger Sandwiches, Tartlet Shells with Chicken Salad, Heart Shaped Cheesemold w/Assorted Crackers, Fruit Kabobs, Mini Quiche, Crab and Cheese Triangles, Mushroom Scallion Crescents, Steamed Shrimp, Hot Crab Dip

    • Finger Sandwiches Plus

      $9.95 per person

      Finger Sandwiches, Tartlet Shell with Chicken Salad, Heart Shaped Cheesemold w/Assorted Crackers, Fruit Kabobs, Mini Quiche, Crab and Cheese Triangles, Nuts

    • Grilled Pork Tenderloin

      $18.45 per person

      Grilled Pork Tenderloin, Smoked Turkey, Rolls w/Homemade Mustard and Herb Mayonnaise, Hot Spinach Dip w/Crispy Flour Tortillas, Hot Chipped Beef Dip w/Pumpernickel, Assorted Vegetable Tray w/ Dips, Artichoke Tartlets, Parmesan Rounds, Assorted Fruit Tray, Steamed Shrimp

    • Roll Up Sandwiches & Wings

      Roll Up Sandwiches & Wings

      $10.95 per person

      Roll Up Sandwiches, Vegetable and Fruit Tray w/Assorted Dips, Cheesemold w/Assorted Crackers, Oriental Wings, Hot Broccoli and Cheese Dip w/Crispy Flour Tortilla, Assorted Bar Cookies, Nuts

    • Sliced Beef Tenderloin

      Sliced Beef Tenderloin

      $18.45 per person

      Sliced Beef Tenderloin, Yeast Rolls w/Homemade Mustard and Herb Mayonnaise, Savory Tartlets, Assorted Vegetables w/Dip, Crab Claws (Subj. to availability), Fruit Tray, International Cheese Platter w/Crackers, Hot Vidalia Onion Dip, Swedish Meatballs, Tartlet Shells with Shrimp Salad, Salted Roasted Pecans

    • Smoked Ham

      $9.95 per person

      Smoked Ham, Homemade Mustard & Herb Mayonnaise, Yeast Rolls, Vegetable Tray w/ Dip, Cheesemold w/ Crackers, Mexican Dip with Tortillas, Assorted Sweets

    • Smoked Ham and Turkey

      Smoked Ham and Turkey

      $14.95 per person

      Smoked Ham and Turkey, Mini Yeast Rolls, Homemade Mustard and Herb Mayonnaise, Cheesemold w/Crackers, Cucumber Cups w/Crab Filling, Cherry Tomatoes w/Herb Filling, Shrimp-Filled Tartlet Shells, Assorted Fruit Tray, Chocolate-Dipped Strawberries

    • Smoked Turkey and Beef

      $16.25 per person

      Smoked Turkey and Beef, Yeast Rolls w/Homemade Mustard and Herb Mayonnaise, Assorted Fruit and Cheese Tray w/Crackers, Cucumber Cups w/Crab Filling, Cherry Tomatoes w/Herb Filling, Tartlet Shells with Chicken Salad, Grilled Smoke Sausage w/Honey Mustard, Assorted Sweets: Chocolate Dipped Strawberries, Truffles, Lemon and Blueberry Tartlets

    • Desserts

    • Apple Pie

      $15.00

      (9 inch pie)

    • Blueberry Tartlett

      $3.00 per dozen

    • Buckeyes

      $6.00 per dozen

    • Buttercake Cookies

      $20.00 per quarter sheet

    • Buttermilk Pie

      $12.00

      (9 inch pie)

    • Cappuccino Torte

      $45.00 each

    • Chocolate Cheesecake

      $30.00

      (12 inch cake)

    • Chocolate Peanut Butter Bars

      $25.00 per quarter sheet

    • Chocolate Truffles

      $6.00 per dozen

    • Decorated Butter Cookies

      $6.00 per dozen

      (1.5 inch cookie decorated with poured fondant and a drop flower)

    • Four Layer Kahlua Brownies

      Four Layer Kahlua Brownies

      $60.00 per half sheet

    • Homemade Cookies

      $5.00 per dozen

      (Chocolate Chip, Oatmeal, Peanut Butter)

    • Iced Brownies

      $20.00 per quarter sheet

    • Large Cheesecake

      $30.00

      (12 inch cake)

    • Lemon Bars

      $20.00 per quarter sheet

    • Lemon Chess Pie

      $12.00

      (9 inch pie)

    • Lemon Tartletts

      $3.00 per dozen

    • Mini Cheesecake

      $5.00 per dozen

    • Peanut Butter Fingers

      $35.00 per quarter sheet

    • Pecan Pie

      $20.00

      (9 inch pie)

    • Pecan Tassies

      $8.00 per dozen

    • Small Cheesecake

      $25.00

      (9 inch cake)

    • Sour Cream Pound Cake

      $18.00

      (Bundt style)

    • Lunch/Dinner

    • Apricot Chicken

      $9.95 per person

      Apricot Chicken, Rice Pilaf, Salad, Dessert, Tea

    • Arroz Con Pollo

      $10.25 per person

      Arroz Con Pollo, Salad, Yeast Rolls, Dessert, Iced Tea

    • Baked Chicken Breast

      $9.95 per person

      Baked Chicken Breast, Rice Pilaf, Salad, Rolls, Dessert, Iced Tea

    • Baked Ziti w/Meat Sauce

      $12.95 per person

      Baked Ziti w/Meat Sauce, Salad, Garlic Bread, Dessert, Iced Tea

    • Basil, Tomato, Alfredo Pizza

      $10.95 per person

      Basil, Tomato, Alfredo Pizza, Whole Green Beans, Salad, Dessert, Iced Tea (Add Chicken to Pizza $1.00)

    • Beef Burgundy

      Beef Burgundy

      $14.95 per person

      Beef Burgundy, Rice, Italian Green Beans w/Onion and Basil, Salad, Dessert, Iced Tea

    • Beef Tenderloin w/Roquefort Sauce

      $34.95 per person

      Beef Tenderloin w/Roquefort Sauce, Potato Casserole w/Caramelized Onions, Buttered Asparagus, Marinated Tomatoes, Salad, Rolls, Dessert, Iced Tea

    • Chicken & Pork Paella

      $13.95 per person

      Chicken & Pork Paella, Salad, Rolls, Dessert, Iced Tea

    • Chicken and Wild Rice Casserole

      $11.95 per person

      Chicken and Wild Rice Casserole, Salad, Sautéed Whole Green Beans, Yeast Rolls, Dessert, Iced Tea

    • Chicken Breast Mornay

      $13.95 per person

      Chicken Breast Mornay, Vegetable Medley, Rice Pilaf, Salad, Dessert, Iced Tea

    • Chicken Cordon Bleu

      $17.95 per person

      Chicken Cordon Bleu, Rice Pilaf, Salad, Dessert, Iced Tea

    • Chicken Crepes Mornay

      $17.95 per person

      Chicken Crepes Mornay, Sautéed Vegetable, Yellow Rice, Salad, Rolls, Dessert, Iced Tea

    • Chicken Parmesan

      $13.95 per person

      Chicken Parmesan, Rice Pilaf, Salad, Herb Rolls, Dessert, Iced Tea

    • Chicken Pie

      $12.95 per person

      Chicken Pie, Buttered Peas, Sliced - Marinated Tomatoes, Rolls, Dessert, Iced Tea

    • Chicken Pilau

      $8.95 per person

      Chicken Pilau, Green Salad, Fancy Cornbread, Dessert, Iced Tea

    • Chicken Salad

      $9.95 per person

      Chicken Salad, Fruit Salad, Yeast Rolls, Dessert, Iced Tea

    • Chicken Stroganoff

      $13.95 per person

      Chicken Stroganoff, Noodles or Rice, Broccoli Casserole, Salad, Herb Rolls, Dessert, Iced Tea

    • Chicken Tetrazzini

      $13.95 per person

      Chicken Tetrazzini, Salad, Rolls, Dessert, Iced Tea

    • Chicken/Stuffing Casserole

      $10.95 per person

      Chicken/Stuffing Casserole, Salad, Herb Rolls, Dessert, Iced Tea

    • Chopped Pork

      $9.25 per person

      Chopped Pork, Cole Slaw, Baked Beans, Rolls ( Sandwich optional), Dessert, Tea

    • Company Chicken

      $11.95 per person

      Company Chicken, Rice Pilaf, Salad, Rolls, Dessert, Iced Tea

    • Eggplant Parmesan

      $12.95 per person

      Eggplant Parmesan, Salad, Garlic Bread, Dessert, Tea (Seasonal Price)

    • Glazed Pork Loin

      $14.95 per person

      Glazed Pork Loin, Buttered Baby Carrots and Peas, Lemon Rice, Salad, Rolls, Dessert, Iced Tea

    • Grilled Pork Tenderloin

      Grilled Pork Tenderloin

      $19.95 per person

      Grilled Pork Tenderloin, White and Wild Rice Medley, Spinach Stuffed Tomatoes, Salad, Rolls, Dessert, Iced Tea

    • Herb-Stuffed Pork Loin

      $17.95 per person

      Herb-Stuffed Pork Loin, Rice Pilaf, Whole Baby Carrots, Sweet Potato Biscuit, Salad, Dessert, Iced Tea

    • Lasagna

      $11.95 per person

      Lasagna (vegetable or meat), Salad, Rolls, Dessert, Iced Tea

    • Meatloaf

      $9.25 per person

      Meatloaf, Mashed Potatoes, Green Beans, Rolls, Dessert, Iced Tea

    • Paella

      Paella

      $22.25 per person

      Paella, Salad, Herb Rolls, Dessert, Iced Tea

    • Prime Rib

      $24.25 per person

      Prime Rib (6-8 oz.), Sautéed Seasonal Vegetables, Garlic Mashed Potatoes, Salad, Rolls, Dessert, Iced Tea

    • Quiche

      $8.95 per person

      Quiche, Sliced Tomatoes, Whole Green Beans, Rolls, Dessert, Iced Tea

    • Rosemary Garlic Roasted Chicken

      Rosemary Garlic Roasted Chicken

      $13.95 per person

      Rosemary Garlic Roasted Chicken, Lemon Parsley Rice, Salad, Rolls, Dessert, Iced tea

    • Seafood Crepes Mornay

      $19.95 per person

      Seafood Crepes Mornay, Rice Pilaf, Sautéed Sugar Snaps, Salad, Rolls, Dessert, Iced Tea

    • Seasoned Grilled Sirloin Tip Roast

      Seasoned Grilled Sirloin Tip Roast

      $14.95 per person

      Seasoned Grilled Sirloin Tip Roast, Oven-Roasted Potatoes, Broccoli, Salad, Rolls, Dessert, Iced Tea

    • Shrimp Creole

      $18.45 per person

      Shrimp Creole, Buttered Rice, Sautéed Vegetable Medley, Salad, Rolls, Iced Tea

    • Smoked Chicken

      $10.25 per person

      Smoked Chicken, Potato Casserole, Salad, Rolls, Dessert, Iced Tea

    • Smoked Ham

      $9.95 per person

      Smoked Ham, Potato Casserole, Green Beans, Rolls, Dessert, Iced Tea

    • Smothered Fried Pork Chops

      $10.95 per person

      Smothered Fried Pork Chops, Mashed Potatoes, Salad or Vegetable, Rolls, Dessert, Tea

    • Spaghetti w/Meat Sauce

      $9.95 per person

      Spaghetti w/Meat Sauce, Salad, Garlic Bread, Dessert, Iced Tea

    • Tomato Pie

      $10.95 per person

      Tomato Pie, Whole Green Beans, Salad, Rolls, Dessert, Iced Tea

    • Tuscan Chicken

      Tuscan Chicken

      $14.95 per person

      Tuscan Chicken, Garlic Herbed Mashed Potatoes, Asparagus w/Lemon Butter, Rolls, Dessert, Iced Tea

    • Vegetable/Meat Quiche

      $9.25 per person

      Vegetable/Meat Quiche, Salad, Yeast Rolls, Dessert, Iced Tea

Prices and menu items subject to change based on availability.

*Each Half sheet yields approximately 90 small pieces
*Each Quarter sheet yields approximately 40-45 small pieces

x